Swift V Macbean [work] Jun 2026

The defendants argued the lease was frustrated because the premises were requisitioned by the government for wartime use, depriving them of the benefit of the lease. The Decision: Birkett J. held that the doctrine of frustration does not apply to leases

Birkett J. held that the , regardless of whether they were for furnished or unfurnished premises. The reasoning was rooted in the nature of a lease as more than just a contract; it is a conveyance of an estate in land. Even if the tenant is deprived of physical possession by a third party (like the government), the legal "estate" still exists, and the obligation to pay rent remains. Significance and Legacy Certainty of Leasehold Terms: A Legal Analysis - Studylib

: In March 1941, during the war, the local authority requisitioned the house and its furniture for government use. The tenants refused to pay rent, claiming the lease had been frustrated.

: At the time of this ruling, English law held that the contractual position between a landlord and tenant was largely unaffected by external events like government requisitioning. A tenant was not excused from paying rent even if they lost possession, as the lease was viewed as a transfer of an estate in land.

The ship set sail from London bound for Jamaica with a general cargo. Shortly after departing, the vessel encountered a severe gale in the English Channel. The storm was so violent that the ship began to leak heavily. Despite the crew manning the pumps continuously for several hours, the water in the hold rose to dangerous levels.

Yet, history often remembers the clashes of titans—Swift versus Addison, Swift versus Pope, or Swift versus the entire Whig establishment. Less remembered, but perhaps more illuminating of Swift’s character and the literary culture of the time, is his bizarre and relentless persecution of a minor Scottish poet named John MacBean.

Commence upon the between Great Britain and Germany. Continue until the end of hostilities .