American Sports Story Aaron Hernandez - Episode 10 Jun 2026

The episode centers on Aaron’s (Josh Andrés Rivera) second trial for the 2012 double homicide of Daniel de Abreu and Safiro Furtado.

He references a fictionalized (but thematically accurate) conversation with Coach Belichick early in his Patriots career, where Belichick allegedly told him, “In this league, you are a tight end. Nothing else. No distractions. You belong to the game.”

In one of the episode’s most powerful sequences, Hernandez has a violent outburst over a TV remote, only to collapse into tears moments later, unable to explain why he snapped. A prison therapist suggests he write a letter to his daughter, Avielle. This act of writing becomes the episode’s narrative spine. American Sports Story Aaron Hernandez - Episode 10

“They tell me I’m a monster, baby girl. But monsters don’t cry in the shower. Monsters don’t remember being 12 years old and feeling things for boys that made my father’s belt look like mercy.”

Throughout the episode, Aaron is plagued by auditory hallucinations of sports radio hosts mocking his sexuality and legacy. His mental health deteriorates rapidly in prison, exacerbated by hostile courtyard fights and severe physical symptoms of brain trauma. The CTE Diagnosis and Scientific Context The episode centers on Aaron’s (Josh Andrés Rivera)

This article contains detailed plot points for Episode 10 of American Sports Story .

In the grim, unflinching finale of American Sports Story , titled “Who Among You is Without Sin?”, the FX anthology series completes its tragic arc not with a touchdown, but with a whimper behind bars. Episode 10 chronicles the final days of Aaron Hernandez (played with haunting vulnerability by Josh Rivera), moving from the spectacle of his 2017 acquittal for a double murder to his lonely suicide in a Massachusetts prison cell. No distractions

Here is everything you need to know about the series finale, how it handles the death of Aaron Hernandez, and what the show is trying to say about the American sports machine that enabled him.

Unlike the tabloid headlines, Episode 10 focuses on Hernandez’s internal war with his sexuality and his toxic upbringing. Through voiceover, we hear him draft the letter:

One of the most striking aspects of Episode 10 is its thoughtful exploration of Hernandez's psychological state. The episode features interviews with experts who provide insight into the mind of a man who seemed to have it all – wealth, fame, and a loving family – yet was driven to commit unspeakable acts of violence.